Regional Plan Association celebrates a century of research, planning, and advocacy

  • the latest
  • about
    • Who We Are

    • About RPA
    • Our Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • Committees
    • Join Our Team
    • Financials
    • History

    • Regional Plans
    • Timeline
    • Centennial
  • contact
  • search
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Vimeo
  • Our Work

    Reports

    View and search the archive of RPA reports.

    View All

    Campaigns

    Learn about our ongoing advocacy work.

    View All

    Research Areas

    • Energy & Environment
    • Housing & Neighborhood Planning
    • Transportation
    • Governance
  • Our Region
  • Events

    Upcoming Events

    Discover upcoming events.

    View All

    Assembly

    Learn more about our annual spring conference.

    • 2023 Assembly
    • Sponsorship Opportunities
    • Past Assemblies

    Benefit

    Learn more about our fall celebration.

    View

  • Support
  • Our Work
    • Reports
    • Campaigns
    • Research Areas

    • Energy & Environment
    • Housing & Neighborhood Planning
    • Transportation
    • Governance
  • Our Region
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • 2023 Assembly
    • Benefit
  • Support
  • the latest
  • about
    • Who We Are

    • About RPA
    • Our Staff
    • Board of Directors
    • Committees
    • Join Our Team
    • Financials
    • History

    • Regional Plans
    • Timeline
    • Centennial
  • contact
  • search
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Vimeo

Dec 08 2020

Testimony

Testimony on NYCHA's "Blueprint for Change" Proposal to Streamline Operations and Address Capital Needs

share

Thank you for the opportunity to submit testimony. RPA is a non-profit civic organization that conducts research, planning, and advocacy to improve economic opportunity, mobility, environmental sustainability, and the quality of life for those who live and work in the New York metropolitan region.

We would like to applaud the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) for its recent ​“Blueprint for Change” and the New York Assembly for introducing 11149 establishing the Housing Preservation Trust. This is a needed and necessary step toward returning our Public Housing back to a state of good repair.

In particular we are pleased to see the dedication to keeping public housing public, leveraging the use of federal funding streams such as Section 18 and Tenant Protection Vouchers, and more flexible approaches to capital work such as design-build. This trust would be a vast improvement on the current ability of the city and NYCHA to address capital needs in a timely and effective manner, while still retaining the things that make public housing one of the best housing assets to the City and the people who live here: public ownership, tenant protection, and affordable rents - especially to those without incomes high enough for other affordable housing options.

In terms of the composition of the Board of Directors for the Preservation Trust, we note that all appointees are ultimately accountable to the Mayor, either through direct appointment or through appointment by an official (the NYCHA Chair) appointed by the Mayor. While a majority of the Board should be appointed by the Mayor, and the trust itself, like NYCHA, ultimately accountable to the Mayor, in the interest of both transparency and inclusiveness some adjustments should be made to its composition.

First, at least one other citywide elected official should have a direct appointment to the board of the Preservation Trust.

Second, at least one member on the board should be selected by and accountable to NYCHA residents themselves. The Citywide Council of Presidents structure provides a means to democratically selecting this representative already, although it would not necessarily need to be the way NYCHA residents could select a representative on the board.

We would also like to reinforce support for several suggestions made by Community Service Society and NYC Legal Aid in their testimony. These include:

  • Clarification of the body charged with oversight of the Preservation Trust.
  • A requirement that Board Meetings be open and allow for public input.
  • An additional bill providing for funding independent technical assistance to residents affected by Preservation Trust conversion plans.
  • Clarification that all resident rights and protections will be carried over, including succession rights and participation in resident councils and CCoP, and that these rights and protections will be available to future as well as current residents, and the PACT/RAD standards be adopted in regards to residency rights of return.
  • Give a preference to non-profit, mission-oriented organizations for any outside contracting of management. In addition, residents should have a direct say in any new management company brought in.
  • Building conditions and violations should be recorded in the public DOB and HPD databases, and be subjects to the same inspection and violation process as privately-owned housing.

Lastly, we would like to emphasize that time is of the essence in terms of effecting this legislation. With conditions in NYCHA already at the breaking point and deteriorating daily, it is necessary to create and empower this entity as soon as possible. Both the Assembly Housing Committee, as well as the NY State Legislature as a whole, should make this the highest priority.

RPA appreciates the time offered by the New York State Assembly Standing Committee on Housing. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Written by

  • Gates Moses

    Moses Gates

    Vice President, Housing & Neighborhood Planning

Related Testimony Posts

Mar 2023
in Housing & Neighborhood Planning
Municipal Art Society and Regional Plan Association Launch Interactive Webtool and Release Report on Citywide Environmental Review Process
Mar 2023
in Housing & Neighborhood Planning
New Regional Plan Association Report Proposes Solutions to Speed the Delivery of Modern Street Infrastructure and Save NYC Over $1 Billion Per Year
Dec 2022
in Housing & Neighborhood Planning
New Regional Plan Association Report Finds Reducing NYC Parking Minimums Key to Combating Affordable Housing Crisis
Aug 2022
in Housing & Neighborhood Planning
First Test of the ​“City That Says ​‘Yes’ ”

Receive our monthly newsletter, insider updates and exclusive invitations to RPA events.

become a member today

New York

One Whitehall St
16th Floor
New York, NY 10004

New Jersey

179 Nassau Street
3rd Floor
Princeton, NJ 08542

60 Union Street
Suite 1-N
Newark, NJ 07105

Connecticut

2 Landmark Square
Suite 108
Stamford, CT 06901

Connect

  • 212.253.2727
  • info@rpa.org
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Vimeo

Want to get involved?

Sign up for our newsletter to hear about the latest reports and events.

sign up

All content 2023. All rights reserved. .